Do Shallots Make You Cry

Amidst the hustle of the kitchen, the humble shallot sits quietly in the shadows of its more robust relatives, the onions.

Yet, when its layers unfurl under the knife, a familiar tingle may begin to well in your eyes.

This culinary conundrum, so common yet often overlooked, begs investigation.

With the wisdom of an experienced culinary guide, let's navigate the lesser-known waters of the shallot, revealing how this small ingredient can have a big impact on your cooking—and possibly your tear ducts.

Key Takeaways

  • Shallots release enzymes called alliinases when chopped, which leads to the production of syn-propanethial-S-oxide, the compound that irritates the eyes and causes tears.
  • Shallots cause less eye irritation compared to onions due to their smaller size and gentler flavor.
  • Cutting techniques such as using a sharp blade, refrigerating shallots before chopping, adopting a quick and precise slicing technique, and managing airflow can help reduce tear production.
  • While shallots may still cause tears, the amount of syn-propanethial-S-oxide can vary between different types of the Allium family, and individual reactions to the chemical may vary.

The Science of Tears

Understanding why shallots cause eyes to water involves examining the biological processes that occur when these aromatic vegetables are cut. When you chop a shallot, its cells break open, and enzymes named alliinases are released. These substances facilitate the conversion of amino acid sulfoxides into sulfenic acids. These sulfenic acids then quickly transform into a volatile substance called syn-propanethial-S-oxide (C3H6OS).

When this gas makes contact with your eyes, it combines with the water in your tear films to create a mild sulfuric acid. This irritant prompts the sensory neurons in your eyes to initiate a reflex designed to produce tears to dilute and remove the irritant. The watering of the eyes experienced is a direct result of the chemical reaction that takes place when the cells of the shallot are disturbed.

Shallots Vs. Onions

Shallots can cause tears through their chemical reactions, and it is interesting to see how they stack up against onions in this regard, since both are part of the Allium family and possess similar properties that induce tears. The main compound responsible for causing the eyes to water in both shallots and onions is called syn-propanethial-S-oxide, which is emitted when the cells of these plants are broken, such as when they're being cut.

To highlight their differences and similarities, refer to the table below:

Property Shallots Onions
Size Smaller Larger
Flavor Gentler, with a hint of sweetness Sharp, with a stronger taste
Tear-inducing Less, due to their compact size Greater, due to their larger size
Usage Favored in gourmet cooking Widely used in a variety of recipes

It's noticeable that shallots typically cause less eye irritation; their compact size means fewer cuts are needed, thus lessening the release of irritating substances.

Chemical Compounds Involved

Cutting shallots and onions often results in tears due to syn-propanethial-S-oxide, a volatile substance produced when the enzyme alliinase interacts with the amino acid isoalliin within the vegetable's cells. Breaking the cell walls of a shallot during cutting initiates this enzyme-driven process. The syn-propanethial-S-oxide formed is an irritant to the eyes, causing the lachrymal glands to release tears to try to remove it.

Alliinase is notably susceptible to heat and becomes inactive at moderate temperatures. Cooking shallots before chopping can reduce or prevent the production of tears. If you must handle them uncooked, cooling the shallots before you slice them can decrease the activity of the enzyme, lessening the release of the irritating agent and helping to protect your eyes.

Cutting Techniques to Reduce Tears

To reduce the chance of tears while slicing shallots, use methods such as employing a keen blade, which decreases cellular harm and thus lessens the emission of irritating substances. Make sure the knife edge is finely honed; a blunt blade causes undue squashing and wider dispersal of syn-propanethial-S-oxide, the chemical that irritates the eyes. Refrigerating shallots before you chop them can also reduce enzyme activity, leading to a lessened amount of irritants.

Adopt a quick and precise slicing technique to speed up the task and minimize the time you're exposed. Work on a steady chopping board to keep control and diminish the chances of cell breakage. Also, manage the flow of air away from your face by arranging a fan or using a ventilation hood to move airborne irritants away from you. These careful steps can greatly alleviate reactions that cause tearing.

Myths About Shallots and Crying

In the many tales of the kitchen, it's often thought that shallots won't make you cry as much as onions do. This deserves a closer examination.

Both shallots and onions contain syn-Propanethial-S-oxide, which causes tears. How much you cry depends on how much of this chemical is in the vegetable, and this amount can vary between different types of the Allium family.

Shallots, with a chemical makeup not unlike onions, can also cause tears, maybe to a smaller extent due to differences in the levels of syn-Propanethial-S-oxide.

It's also key to recognize that how a person reacts to this chemical can differ, so your response to cutting shallots mightn't be the same as someone else's.

Preventative Measures for Tear-Free Cooking

Understanding that both shallots and onions can cause your eyes to water, let's now look at the methods you can use to reduce this issue while cooking. Considering the root cause, we see that cutting shallots releases a gas known as propanethial S-oxide. This gas, when it comes into contact with any moist surface, such as the eyes, transforms into sulfuric acid, which is responsible for the burning feeling and the tears.

Here's a detailed table of measures to prevent this:

Method How It Works
Refrigerating Decreases the activity of enzymes and gas
Using a Sharp Blade Minimizes cellular damage, reducing gas released
Improving Air Flow Moves irritants away from your eyes
Eye Protection Acts as a barrier to stop irritants

Using these techniques will help reduce the chance of causing your eyes to water, ensuring a more enjoyable time in the kitchen.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can Eating Shallots Raw Have the Same Tear-Inducing Effect as Cutting Them?

Eating raw shallots typically doesn't cause tears since you aren't releasing the compounds that occur when cutting, which is what usually irritates your eyes and triggers crying.

Are There Any Long-Term Effects on Eye Health From Frequently Crying Due to Cutting Shallots or Onions?

You're in luck; frequent shallot-induced tears don't harm your eyes long-term. They're like a brief rainstorm, clearing irritants with no lasting damage, as your eyes are remarkably resilient and self-healing.

How Does the Tear Response to Shallots Compare to Other Types of Alliums, Like Garlic or Leeks?

When comparing alliums, shallots trigger a milder tear response than onions but more so than garlic or leeks, due to their varying levels of syn-Propanethial-S-oxide, the chemical causing eye irritation.

Can Pets, Like Dogs or Cats, Experience the Same Tearful Reaction When Exposed to Shallots?

Ever wondered if your pets tear up like you might when chopping shallots? They don't, because their tear response to irritants isn't as sensitive as humans', especially concerning the compounds in alliums like shallots.

Is There a Difference in the Crying Response Between Consuming Cooked Shallots in a Dish Versus Handling and Chopping Them Raw?

When you consume cooked shallots, you're unlikely to cry because cooking neutralizes the compounds that cause tears. However, chopping raw shallots can make you tear up due to these released irritants.


In conclusion, like peeling back the layers of an enigmatic puzzle, you've unraveled the science behind teary kitchen encounters. Shallots do incite tears, albeit less aggressively than onions.

By understanding the chemical warfare these bulbs wage and employing precise cutting techniques, you stand armed to minimize the emotional deluge.

Remember, with the right preventative strategies, tear-free cooking isn't a myth—it's a skillful dance between biology and culinary artistry.

Leave a Comment